Payroll Tax Manager Salary in Buffalo, New York

How much does a Payroll Tax Manager make in Buffalo, NY?

As of April 01, 2025, the average annual salary for a Payroll Tax Manager in Buffalo, NY is $118,398. Salary.com reports that pay typically ranges from $104,609 to $133,926, with most professionals earning between $92,054 and $148,063.

Search Payroll Tax Manager Jobs in Buffalo, NY

How to Become a Tax Manager

Develop a Job description

Pay Equity

2024 Compensation Trend

Benefits Consulting

Salary range for a Payroll Tax Manager

$104,609 to $133,926

Employers: Find Surveys For This Job

Employers: Price Your Company Jobs

View Average Salary for United States
Adjust Payroll Tax Manager Salary:
Select State
Select City in NY
Choose Similar Job
Pick Related Category
View Cost of Living in Buffalo, New York

Facing Salary Structure Challenges? Let Our Expert Guide You

The job market is increasingly challenging. Our whitepaper, Navigating the Challenges of Creating Salary Structures, offers guidance on creating salary structures. Provide your phone number and work email to download the full version.

We will handle your contact details in line with our Privacy Policy. If you prefer not to receive marketing emails from Salary.com, you can opt-out out of marketing communications at any time by clicking unsubscribe.

Payroll Tax Manager

Review the job openings and experience requirements for the Payroll Tax Manager job to confirm that it is the job you are seeking.

See user submitted job responsibilities for Payroll Tax Manager.

Search Payroll Tax Manager Job Openings

Job Openings for Payroll Tax Manager in Buffalo, NY

What does a Payroll Tax Manager do?

Common responsibilities of a Payroll Tax Manager

Creates a team climate of practical and innovative action, facilitating collaboration between competing interests and stakeholders.

November 17, 2022

Demonstrates client orientation and results orientation with a focus on accountability and creating an impact on the mission Ensures successful implementation and delivery of key programs and projects, ensuring that outputs positively impact results.

January 15, 2023

Prepare detailed verification, review, reconciliation and preparation of payroll tax remittances either internally or through the external vendor.

January 18, 2023

Develops and implements solutions that show understanding of how clients and/or own work achieves results that are financially, environmentally and socially sustainable.

February 22, 2023

Reconciles payroll tax reporting after each pay run to ensure accurate remittance and filing of data that is sent to the tax service provider.

March 19, 2023

Support legal and tax compliance and be point of contact for requests from Corporate Legal, Finance, and Tax departments.

May 13, 2023

Submit Other Responsibilities

Not the job you're looking for? Search more salaries here:

Are you an HR manager or compensation specialist?

Salary.com's CompAnalyst platform offers:

Detailed skills and competency reports for specific positions
Job and employee pricing reports
Compensation data tools, salary structures, surveys and benchmarks.

Learn about

Payroll Tax Manager Salary By Experience Levels in Buffalo, NY

How much should you be earning in Payroll Tax Manager in Buffalo, NY based on your current experience?

Tell us how much experience you have and see an estimate of earnings and view how different experience leavels impact potential pay for Payroll Tax Manager in Buffalo, NY

RELEVANT JOB EXPERIENCE

Length of experience is a pay differentiator. Those with greater experience may have an advantage in negotiating salary. For those with less experience, other factors such as education or special skills could impact your pay. Please visit Professional Salary Report for more details.

Payroll Tax Manager Salary By Level of Education in Buffalo, NY

Do you know how much should you be paid for a Payroll Tax Manager position in Buffalo, NY based on your education level?

Tell us about your education and see an estimate of earnings for Payroll Tax Manager in Buffalo, NY and well to know the impact of education on future careers.

LEVEL OF EDUCATION

Depending on the job, educational levels may have a significant impact on pay levels. Be informed and understand how things like education and certifications can help to increase potential earnings for the career you are interested in. Please visit Professional Salary Report for more details.

Average Salary Range for Payroll Tax Manager in Buffalo, NY

Average Base Salary

Core compensation

104609

133926

118398

Average Total Cash Compensation

Includes base and annual incentives

110978

147081

127466

What is the average salary for Payroll Tax Manager in 2025?

These charts show the average base salary (core compensation), as well as the average total cash compensation for the job of Payroll Tax Manager in Buffalo, NY. The base salary for Payroll Tax Manager ranges from $104,609 to $133,926 with the average base salary of $118,398. The total cash compensation, which includes base, and annual incentives, can vary anywhere from $110,978 to $147,081 with the average total cash compensation of $127,466.

View Average Salary for Payroll Tax Manager as table

	Average Salary	Average Salary Range
Base Salary	$118,398	$104,609 - $133,926
Bonus	$9,068	$6,370 - $13,155
Total Pay	$127,466	$110,978 - $147,081

* Base Salary represents gross income before taxes and deductions. It does not include additional pay such as benefits, bonuses, profit sharing or commissions.

* Total Pay combines base salary, bonuses, profit sharing, tips, commissions, overtime pay and other forms of cash earnings, as applicable for this job.

Payroll Tax Manager Salary Near Buffalo, NY

CITY, STATE	AVERAGE SALARY RANGE	COMPARE TO Buffalo, NY
CITY, STATE Niagara Falls, NY	AVERAGE SALARY RANGE $104,392 - $133,649	COMPARE TO Buffalo, NY
CITY, STATE Jamestown, NY	AVERAGE SALARY RANGE $102,662 - $131,433	COMPARE TO Buffalo, NY
CITY, STATE Henrietta, NY	AVERAGE SALARY RANGE $106,101 - $135,837	COMPARE TO Buffalo, NY
CITY, STATE Rochester, NY	AVERAGE SALARY RANGE $106,101 - $135,837	COMPARE TO Buffalo, NY
CITY, STATE Erie, PA	AVERAGE SALARY RANGE $98,508 - $126,115	COMPARE TO Buffalo, NY
CITY, STATE Syracuse, NY	AVERAGE SALARY RANGE $107,908 - $138,149	COMPARE TO Buffalo, NY

See salaries for Payroll Tax Manager in locations close to Buffalo, NY. Pay for the same job may vary based on the location and on the location and on other factors such as the size of company, the industry, and other local conditions.

About Buffalo, New York

Buffalo is the second largest city in the U.S. state of New York and the largest city in Western New York. As of July 2016[update], the population was 256,902. The city is the county seat of Erie County and a major gateway for commerce and travel across the Canada–United States border, forming part of the bi-national Buffalo Niagara Region. The Buffalo area was inhabited before the 17th century by the Native American Iroquois tribe and later by French settlers. The city grew significantly in the 19th and 20th centuries as a result of immigration, the construction of the Erie Canal and rail tra...

Source: Wikipedia (as of 04/11/2019). Read more from Wikipedia

View Salary for Similar Jobs to Payroll Tax Manager in Buffalo, NY

See Additional Similar Jobs

Loading results...

JOB TITLE	LOCATION	MINIMUM SALARY	MAXIMUM SALARY
JOB TITLE Payroll Manager	LOCATION Buffalo, NY	MINIMUM SALARY $96,894	MAXIMUM SALARY $117,200
JOB TITLE Payroll Supervisor	LOCATION Buffalo, NY	MINIMUM SALARY $81,817	MAXIMUM SALARY $100,204
JOB TITLE Payroll Tax Analyst	LOCATION Buffalo, NY	MINIMUM SALARY $69,844	MAXIMUM SALARY $86,269
JOB TITLE Payroll Tax Administrator	LOCATION Buffalo, NY	MINIMUM SALARY $57,150	MAXIMUM SALARY $72,869
JOB TITLE Payroll Tax Specialist	LOCATION Buffalo, NY	MINIMUM SALARY $77,892	MAXIMUM SALARY $97,707
JOB TITLE Payroll Tax Supervisor	LOCATION Buffalo, NY	MINIMUM SALARY $84,726	MAXIMUM SALARY $110,038

The Payroll Tax Manager job could be listed using titles that are not exactly the same, but actually are for the same or very similar job. Here are some job titles in Buffalo, NY that might be a good fit for the type of job and salary you are looking for.

Discover how your pay is adjusted for skills, experience, and other factors

How much should you be paid?

For a real-time salary target, tell us more about your role in the four categories below.